Romance astarion as a good character reddit Firstly, I have to say I'm playiang as a chaotic neutral character and romance Astarion (I'm totally not obsessed with him). But you will need to trigger Astarion's act 2 romance scene before Gale's to do this. Astarion, I feel has very nice resolution as a close friend and as a romance option. while i don't play a lawful good character, definitely more chaotic good/chaotic neutral, i'm definitely always going the good paths and helping people, and while he's not a fan of that, a lot So, you want to romance everyone's carnage-loving vampire without sacrificing your character's alignment? Now you don't have to! Here is a straight-forward guide to hitting those "Astarion approves" we all love while not feeling guilty I'm also tired of people saying you can't romance Astarion as a goody two shoes, like please, that's rookie talk. For good playthrough, It might sound weird to romance Wyll but I think the hero/monster dynamic would be fun. Thus there was no celebration in the camp and no opportunity to start a romance. As others said; he mostly rolls his eyes, likes when you're silly or rude and there are a bunch of moments that will give you a big approval boost. Here are my observations and suggestions after finishing my Tav's story and watching vids of alternative routes, organised according to the acts of the game. You get double approval for feeding and then petting the OwlBear cub, double approval for admiring His Majesty (arguably Astarion’s spirit animal), and he disapproves of you telling Gale’s tressym friend to stop eating pigeons. I'm a total goody two shoes in games, always, (I even played my Durge as a total cinnamon roll) and successfully romanced Astarion twice. In previous playthroughs I have played a cleric and a bard. He doesn’t so much disapprove of you being good, he disapproves of you “playing hero” when there’s no perceived benefit. Happy Endings guaranteed. Given the whole undead romance as a 'holy warrior' thematic, there can be some juicy conflicts in there if you want to rp it like that The main thing I keep coming back to is that Astarion is not a good-aligned character at his heart. There's no need to do evil things to impress him, you can support him in quests and dialogues. Either way, you can't go wrong. I played a straightforward barbarian character with two braincells who had sex with Astarion because he liked Astarion and Astarion was hitting on him. You could also try moving him far enough away from the party that he isn’t included in certain dialogue interactions (to save constantly swapping him out from the This playthrough I’m wanting to romance Astarion. I gave up and decided to romance Wyll. You know, unless that's your kink. 1. You have an excuse storywise, you can still have good approval with them as a good character and they have good character arcs. I won't spoil but his romance as a good-aligned Tav or a resisting Durge (especially a resisting Durge) is very satisfying. I am not a big fan of when a story makes the character's happiness (and in some cases, survival) depend on romantic involvement, and I think it would be a especially bad resolution for someone with a story like Astarion. This throws a wrench in my "I'm going to have Tav romance Gale this patch" plans, because I just can't say no to Astarion lol. Shadowheart refused to kill the nightsong, Durge refused to kill Isobel, now you work together to save Shadowheart. Or is that impossible given that the dark urge is already a spawn. Astarion basically loves drama, chaos, and selfishness. (a soy boy. At first, Astarion disapproved of a lot of decisions I made too. Freedom - true freedom. The fact that they went though the trouble of revoicing and animating essentially the same lines where they could easily have recycled them is such a neat detail. Sure, the full game isn't out yet and we don't know Astarion's entire story. Astarion approves for 5 whole points and calls you cheeky. Both have arcs really involved in the story, and I like both of their potential 'good-aligned' endings. Is it possible to romance Astarion when playing as a good character? I don't use tadpoles, necromancy of Thay etc. A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. And respecting his autonomy. Astarion: And as you're my consort, that makes us the most powerful people in the world. Lea'zel has new perspective, but she can (and mostly probably will) leave (go Lea'zel!). I had already made most of the decisions in act 1 as a good character but I did what was left in a way to get astarion approval up, using the approval up guide on fextralife. Most of the "Say something good, Astarion disapproves" is just -1 approval, where things like defending him or letting him drink your blood is bigger bonuses, like +5 or +10. But the romance was weird. It’s not as fitting as it is for Minthara, as an example. My character is very accepting and understanding of everyone's quirks, so I don't see Astarion's 'condition' as being a deal breaker. 8/10 Astarion. As spoiler-free as possible: Astarion starts out as an evil-aligned companion on a neutral path. Astarion enjoys doing bad things for a laugh but he won't do stuff he'd have to take consequences for. Absolutely yes! Just finished my romance arc with him, I feel like it adds so much more to where his back story came from, especially depending on particular major choices later on, without being spoilery. The romance should proceed as follows in act II: go to Last Light Inn and talk to Raphael with Astarion in your party defeat Raphaels enemy Long rest. He would sell out anyone to save his own hide. Lol You can play a good character and still romance him, too. I have had Astarion in my party every single time and boy does he dislike that. Astarion's actually not that hard to get approval for even when playing a typical good guy. Astarion doesn't have a race preference, but if it's all the same for you, I would go Tiefling. r/RomanceBooks is a discussion sub for readers of romance novels. I'm inherently the chaotic good style player, so it worked well for the relationship with him. so things like telling Auntie Ethel in the druid camp about your tadpole, letting the Loviatar guy whip you in the goblin camp, etc. The only time he appreciates “good” stuff is when it benefits him specifically. I don't know how far in the game you are yet, but this might be a good thread to check out. Astarion does take longer (oddly though he's faster to raise than Wyll but that's mostly because of the order I do things in) If you haven't seen Astarion's full romance yet and you like his character then I'd say play as Gale. I played DU as "good on the outside, cannot resist my urges in privite" sort of thing, and can make following points: - Astarion is very supportive of anything that makes you lose control over yourself if you romance him, so if you are playing like - I dont wanna be like this - he is going to support you, he values freedom before good or evil I plan on going for Astarion next, the problem is that I like to play the good guy: running around helping everyone and making friends is how I enjoy the game the most. I just didn’t know if It’s a “good”playthrough, and so i’ve kind of struggled to raise Astarion’s approval. Helped by the fact that it's so surprising. My evil female Drow saw him as nothing but eye candy and used him for sex then dumped him for Minthara. I really enjoyed both, so I would be willing to play either of them again, but I might want to try something new too. I did Astarion’s romance with Tav and it was deeply rewarding and surprising. I started an Astarion origin to romance Karlach and did my best to be a sarcastic bastard. PLEASE READ THIS CAREFULLY: DO NOT SKIP. I had no issue getting enough approval with him to start his romance on my evil durge and I wasn’t even trying to. I didn’t know about the moving the character out of the room to avoid disapproval thank you for that tip! I definitely do wish that we could romance these characters even if our alignment doesn’t match theirs directly though, It’d be cool if larian maybe played around with the approval system a little differently, Either way guess I’m just leaving Astarion outside sometimes 😅 He has lots of extra content there, especially within the romance, that Gale doesn't. (Have no idea about Wyll romance at all). Being w You only need to get to medium approval by the time of the party at camp, which isn't too hard even if you're playing a fairly good character. I also told laezel our fling was over. If your approval isn’t high enough to lock the romance in act 2, you can use the drow scene to lock it. Hey guys! I'm trying to romance Astarion as a nice character, but my approval rate doesn't seem to be going up that much. Halsin’s romance is tragically underbaked. Astarion thinks good Tav is naive (I even remember him calling my character this). If you talk and admire them, I usually got approval from Astarion. I did the romance while playing a chaotic mostly good Durge. But the way Lolth-sworn female drow treat males is hard to conciliate Astarion with, a male would fit very well. Apparently we're getting more good aligned characters which is nice, though I do like the companions we have, Wyll is flawed but seems to genuinely be a good person, just a good person with some serious issues and Shadowheart is super sweet when she starts to open up a bit more So I kinda skipped the save/raid the grove quest, because it was out of character for me to help either of the sides. Agreed about Shadowheart. My Tav was totally good (and sometimes chaotic), Astarion's approval was a bit higher than neutral most of the time, with tons of "Astarion disapproves" after each choice, but i still managed to romance and befriend him. Tbh, playing as Durge really makes being a good guy way more rewarding despite the fact people save Durge for evil and murder hobo playthroughs. I romanced (spawn) Astarion twice as Tav and Dark Urge. But it’s better than non romanced spawn Astarion as a companion, if you know what I mean. And that's what a story like Astarion's asks of us--to love him as he needs. I'm having the same struggle in reverse, I meant to romance Shadowheart but Astarion snuck up on me. Things like forcing a goblin to kiss my feet. I'm also excited to see how exactly Astarion grows as well depending on Tav's choices. It just feels SO good. I got pissed and rage quit that campaign. In my opinion, that’s the most fun way to romance him — mostly good characters that won’t pass up having an “edge”, etc. I played a mostly good character but sprinklet in a couple of morally gray decisions. Astarion, as he was the reason I bought the game. If I really put myself in Durge's shoes: Gale, because he is well adjusted and powerful (provided you persuade him out of the whole Crown idea), and he can provide a happy family for Durge (Tara and his mother). Now i'm in the middle of the act 2, Astarion's approval is really really high, but I didn't have any romantic scenes with him at all. Raphael should show up in your camp go to Moonrise Towers, do not (yet) speak with the Drow Long rest again. Very sweet. I choose to spend the night with him at the tiefling party, continue the game as usual. The romance with Astarion is the reason I stopped playing BG3 and had to take a break. Okay y'all, figured it out today - I was able to initiate the romance and get the first scene midway through act 2 by camping in the first area (near Emerald Grove) while at high approval with Astarion and before (this part is probably important) the conversation with the drow who wants him to bite her. This run is not for those who want more Astarion’s voice lines and interactions. After playing so long with Astarion having ”neutral” approval and behaving so coldly towards me (also rejecting my poor Tav at the Tiefling party) I had resigned myself to not being able to romance him while doing a good playthrough. I played him as a good character and decided that he deserves the best for the redemption. Astarion seems more concerned about his character arc in Act 2, though, lol. the character I have most headcanons, background info, just general thoughts about) happens to be a Paladin, well, technically a Sorcadin. Likewise, if you go straight to your bedroll, you can't choose him to spend the night. He’ll be in the party so I can take him everywhere, but I’m not sure what class to make my MC. Honestly, I can't see any justification for a good or evil character to willingly become a slave of Astarion's. Astarion (good path) with a Seldarine Drow Eillestraee Cleric, or Seldarine redeemed Durge is very cute, one of the few good/light deities that could be fine with that romance. Started playing as a custom character, but by the end of act 2 i was more and more intrigued by our vampire companion. He also seems to like cats. What we're presented with is a character who's been through a lot but is still someone worthy of love, compassion and support. I think I should be able to make it work. Typically games don't talk enough about the effects that trauma has on a person, and I think Larian did a good job of showing that through Astarion without making it too explicit/over-indulgent and logical for his character. He also has fangs, so he gets an instant fangbanger boost in the ratings. You are probably not the target audience for him, which is fine. I think its good/bad/evil really depending on your relationship with Astarion. Gandrel only tells the player about his children when Astarion isn't present, so it is metagaming to use that knowledge. ) He just apologizes and hopes you show him some mercy and ideally allow him to slow down the pace of the relationship (abstaining from sex altogether) until he can work some things out regarding intimacy. Drow can have a unique dialogue choice too in one of conversations with another character with Astarion in party, it's not romantic too. Furthremore, most of the scenes that people associate with astarion romance are actually scenes that happen even if you do not romance him. I loved that combo so much, that I instantly started another playthrough as Bard with the sole purpose of romancing him again. For Lae'zel, I think there are several good All I know is that I want to romance Astarion (the one constant in my playthroughs) and I can't be a sorcerer because she is one. Astarion's primary emotional needs in his story arc aren't romance or sex, but safety, companionship and support. Haha I’m excited to start my first durge playthrough soon, I plan to be a rouge and romance Astarion 😂 I hope it’ll be fun Reply reply LumpyVeterinarian835 He has disapproval for a lot of your kind actions, but it doesn't bar romance. ) As a woman, this take makes the most sense to me, and is part of the reason why I romance Astarion every playthrough. Yeah, these are good points. Lae'zel appreciates being straightforward and focused, as well as military cooperation, helping train people and being curious about Gith. Treating him like he's his own person helps a lot, too. it's also quite nice to have a character astarion can't drink from: the dialogue i chose for gale to encourage astarion to only use his teeth on enemies was really fun. I’ve done him, Gale, Wyll, and Shadowheart so far and he’s the one I keep coming back to. Moral dilemmas for both of them make their “good” endings more rewarding. Reply reply I romanced Astarion on my first run and my Tav was a neutral/ chaotic good male drow. Yes, you can absolutely romance him as a good character. I love Astarion's romance in totality, but I've had runs where I rejected his character because the manipulation really didn't feel good. I feel like the ending in which Astarion gets the power and turns you into a vampire to be together forever is a really sad one for a good play-through, and a not-ideal one for an evil play-through. I don't think they would actually be a good pair, but I adore them as unexpected best friends. BG3 is the third main game in the Baldur's Gate series. Evil characters aren't keen on sharing power, let alone handing someone the reins of power over themselves. Feb 11, 2023 · Despite the romance being generally fulfilling there are still things that could use improvements and some extra dialogues and scenes are sorely missing. I play good guy Tav (in a party of Wyll/Gale/Astarion) and usually can get all of them to high/higher. He likes options where you persuade, lie and deceive people, which you can have your character do in good conscience. I find it off putting how every party member is super flirty with my character 24/7. The bite scene, offering him to feed him your blood, the bear one, discussing character’s blood, the mirror scene, and probably even the scars scene… these are all general scenes, not romance ones. After 2 Astarion romance runs I started making characters that just weren't interested because I wanted to check out other romances. You absolutely can romance him and get him to high approval playing a morally good character, and it makes for a very rewarding path. Yeah he is a bit more of an asshole now but I didn't experience anything close to what I've read happens if you are romancing him and let him ascend. Once his approval hit high and I long rested, I got the romance scene that others got during the tiefling party. Then there’s the narrative angle. In the romance, he likes that the ranger doesn't fall for his flowery language and declarations of love. (Jk lol) 3 - Karlach: She’s a character that would probably be ranked one if her story was finished. I didn't romance him, but let him ascend. Enjoyed the DU run more as there was a love story of two redeeming characters who try to start living again. Shadowheart seems to adore me so much I keep thinking it's going to move towards romance, too, but I feel like I'm on the extremely slow burn romance route with her and Gale if she's thinking about it that way at all. Currently, his approval of my Tav is “high”, but try as I might I can’t get it higher. Then at the tiefling party, Astarion had an exclamation point, so I talked to him first and he propositioned me. As much as I like Astarion and Karlach better in a lot of ways, her romance (and her potential character arc in general) is the best in the game. Especially if you're playing a good aligned character. It is very possible to romance him even as a very obviously good-aligned character, I've pulled it off as a Paladin who has never broken his oath even once, and Astarion is still chilling at max approval for me in Act 3, despite me essentially feasting on -1s in Act 1 because I never ask anyone for compensation for doing good. Astarion's mirror scene isn't exclusive to his romance and a good relationship with Astarion is always playful, even if it isn't romantic, because it's his personality. Once you leave act 2 man is kinda Just There. He has a lot of romance options, and is very fleshed out. So I've been wondering myself if I can romance both. Astarion: You know, now that our enemies have fallen, I might be the most powerful person in the world. Dec 13, 2023 · I'm pretty sure it's possible to get enough positive opinion points for romancing Asterion entirely through camp interactions. Extortion and being selfish are good ways to gain approval. The Astarion romance was really well done. i just like that there's a whole arc they have to work through to get to a point where they have something of a good relationship and at least the way i generally play the game (durges leaning more good/toward redemption than anything) there's a lot of parallels and healing for both of them doing that. I know for a fact that there is a good-aligned romantic outcome for his companion quest, so the end result is there - you just need to reach it. Two monsters on a parallel path who find a way to rise above what they were and free themselves form their abusive masters together, and who get to spend the rest of their lives being who THEY want to be, together. As others have confirmed, yes, you can do this. I have a harder time romancing Gale. The odd -1 here and there won’t hurt. So don't think about it and just call him good boy already! "Good boy! Let's get together tonight. Feb 10, 2025 · I find it actually not as easy as many people made me believe. Spent the night with him. and I'm scared that he'll stab me in the back for this. The key is to long rest a lot, and early, since you Astarion has a very good story to tell, and if you listen to his story throughout the game and help his mental state rather than feeding what results from said mental state, you'll get yourself a very rewarding romance. I felt like it fit, but I feel like any combination could work, depending on how you play the game and what story you want to tell romance-wise, which is the beauty of the game. Game screenshot showing Astarion approval Astarion has the more content than any other character with Durge, but if you want someone else then Shadowheart is close second. I tried to romance Astarion while trying for a good character my first playthrough and MY GOD IT WAS HARD. That being said, I feel more like there would be chemistry between Shadowheart and Astarion more in a both using each other while learning to trust someone with yourself for the first time, while I think that Lae'Zel and Minthara (though not actually an Origin character) on a kill the Grove playthrough works very well to me. Most of the time you can do good things and get approval as long as you demand payment or are snarky about it, like asking Lae’zel to say please when you rescue her. He is selfish and cruel. Every day that passes, I gain new abilities. Hmm, my main Tav (i. Now playing good Durge and set out from the beginning to romance Astarion. Some good aligned characters would defend their friend against a perceived threat, others would leave and hope it isn't a problem. The "best" will always be subjective in this sort of thing since it also depends on your liking of different characters and the writing for their romance. It can be annoying watching "Astarion Disapproves" pop up throughout Act 1, but it does simmer down in the later acts. In the beginning of act 1 when my approval was “fair” (exactly 30) with both Astarion and Karlach, and her romance cutscene triggered for me. My party is Laezel, Karlach and Astarion, and it became a struggle since everything I did was going to be disliked by someone. He's probably my favourite part of BG3 so far, his romance feels like it was written by a woman - it hits all the classic notes for a well written bad boy romance character for me (dangerous, flirty, slow to open up but noticably softens to the protag and shows vulnerability, etc). 😭 But he helps and he does the right thing. So good. Playing this game for the first time. its essentially a redeemed durge x Astarion fic but from Astarion's pov and its only made me love Astarion even more! Also I finally caught up a night ago and I looked today and there was like 2 new chapters so yeah its great once you catch up as well bc the author is great with uploading frequently This preference may stem from finding his character engaging compared to the other male characters, whom they perceive as less assertive or dominant. For the Community Wiki, lore, and other details, check out the pinned Weekly Q&A Post. true. This definitely confirms my theory that the Astarion romance on a good-aligned playthrough working so well is 100% intentional and by design. My character is overly good and helps others which he doesn’t approve of, but I did some big approval things for him (let him kill Grandel, let him bite me, didn’t make him bite the blood drow) and then some minor acts that got his approval. You’ll get +5 Astarion approval and -5 Gale approval. I have a big heart for trauma story archs, but Astarion is a superficial, selfish, and dishonest thorn. That was the last romance scene I got with Gale. For now, however, I that befriending him as a good character might be very rewarding. If he's too hard to handle I'll go for Gale There are multiple paths to romance that can be played differently to create very custom PC/Companion ship dynamics in this game, and I encourage you to explore whichever narratives will be the most fun or fulfilling to you personally. Lae'zel and Gale come off as the less obvious choices to me, but I'm sure they are still interesting. Part of that may be playing a character that is into deception (played a charlatan sorcerer, so same background as Astarion) and getting some approval from just tricking people. 124 votes, 78 comments. " Game screenshot showing dialogue decision - good boy. Rogue-ish, sarcastic, hilarious, shady, theatrical etc. I just went through the dream sequence and omg he’s such an asshole to my character it’s both hilarious and sad haha. Second time around I really wanted to romance Wyll and Halsin with my Durge and my Tav (I had two characters on a save), but then went with Astarion and Karlach since I've heard Astarion's romance with Durge was good and I really liked his story, and Karlach's speech at the end of her quest genuinely made me love her as a character, even her Yeah. If they added some extra content for her x Durge in act 3 and fixed/changed her reaction to a certain revelation about your charactert from Gortash I think she'd be the best. Later, my character realized “oh wow, this guy is REALLY traumatized,” felt terrible for him / developed feelings for him, then spent the rest of the game standing up for Astarion i am playing gale origin and romancing astarion. I made every good choice, and I let Astarion do some questionable things (he kept the necromancy of thay, he killed the hunter after him), but once you have the party post-goblin slaughter, you can build a relationship with him, and he will even start approving of The timing of the act 2 "you must murder your beloved" is so good. I went with Astarion, and it was amazing. Since i was a Jesus type TAV I was getting pretty bored with the story. Even without a romance Astarion will find his place in Faerun and make a peace with own personality. The pay off does come, but you aren't wrong for not indulging that. There are plenty of little details that make it fit, too, like Astarion often calling Wyll "sweet" or "too sweet" while Origin Astarion can tell Halsin his secret is that he has a sweet tooth! Wyll's romance is also a very slow burn and chaste compared to the others, which Astarion probably needs. I was wanting to romance Minthara, astarion just happened to want to fuck that night as well so I picked him. He basically went quiet afterwards, and once I reached the outskirts of Baldur's Gate - just when Halsin became available - the option to break up with Gale suddenly appeared. Problem is I also really want to play as a good/kind character and I know Astarion won’t like that. Use telekinesis to throw Cazador near the edge of the platform and had Wyll use the thunderpulse thing that makes a wave to s For example, I think you get considerable amount of points if you let him bite your character early on (I recall reading 20 but don't quote me on this), whereas most disapproval you get from 'helping people' is -1 each. So, I started a new game playing as Astarion instead of Tav, and I had a big question about his act 3 quest: I know that, normally, ascending Astarion with the ritual makes his personality shift and pretty much ruins a romance with him, but does anyone know if anything like that happens if you're playing as him? Exactly this. And they share Durge's plight on a personal level. . Astarion by a mile. As a game, Astarion / SH, because mutual redemption is sweet. Astarion wasn't very happy with some of my choices at first, but it didn't hinder our romance. I havent completed the spawn ending it my game yet, but I've spoiled a lot regarding his endings for myself on Reddit 😂. that are Astarion is the one playable character I cannot stand. astarion, non-ascended path is my favorite romance in the game so i'm extremely biased. My main concern was wether or not he would need to be with someone in order to be okay with his situation. He has some fantastic character development, and his romance is a lot more touching that I ever would've anticipated. You absolutely can romance Astarion as a resisting Urge, and have a good ending. Karlach also seems like she has more stuff going on when you romance her, but that could have just been me missing a few things on the Shart side. ). Gale just got in bed with a literal goddess now he wants to 69 with a 2 foot halfling. i don't get his approval up as quickly as i do gale or wyll or shadowheart, but i always reach very high approval for him and keep it there just in EA. So I’m trying to romance Astarion. I don’t like respeccing the origin characters and so Astarion will be the rogue/lockpicker. Can a resisting dark urge ascend Astarion and become a vampire spawn just like tav. Gods, I romanced Astarion as a chaotic good Bard. But really I haven't found it too diificult to romance and work with him. Yep beat Cazador, You only have 3 turns to kill him before he ascends and completes the ritual and Astarion poofs so this is what I did. Karlach has similar themes in her story as Astarion, so I wonder if there's specific Astarion/Karlach dialogue if you romance her. She’s a character with so much heart (literally) and has gone through a shit load of trauma. I’d put Gale at second best, it’s lighter than Astarion’s romance but still sweet and he’s just a fun character. Spawn Astarion x Good Tav is definitely my canon story. Astarion: It feels so good. I got the scene where he teaches you to cast magic which never triggered in my first run for some reason and she had a lot of cleric specific dialogue for the scene and it kinda got me shipping them a bit they look good together. I have gotten past the bite scene, told him he could feed on me, and have told him about the monster hunter. At least, not a very Roleplay. Good character don't have to act like saints all the time and evil dont need to be saturday morning cartoon villains. Unlocking Astarion’s romance requires specific dialogues and interactions, not necessarily evil actions. Finally. Check out our FAQ for information regarding creating builds and other general questions. This too I don't want to spoil for you, it's in Act 2, though. In re: approval - do not worry too much about it and focus on the big things. And he probably wouldn’t admit it, but he seems to like kids (at least Arabella and he’s worried for the child Ethel eats in Act 3) and animals. When you do good things, he disapproves. Astarion: I can feel my strength growing. Sometimes Astarion disapproves but, mostly, he likes the cheek. I personally liked romancing Lae'zel with a redemption Durge quite a lot, their stories are surprisingly similar since both were under the influence of godlike beings to which they turned Note: I won't recommend playing as Astarion, before act 3 I felt I was playing with a tav that bites, you cannot see the character development that we see when we play tav or another companion! Still, if you play Astarion I recommend romance Gale, he is what Astarion needs and he will not judge him and even offer him a home (if you don't ascend)! Yes, I'm a goody goody Ilmater cleric and I've romanced Astarion this play through. What I would say, if you want to keep Astarion for the utility, just remove him from the party for any big good aligned decisions you make. And then once she gets cooled off, their night together was better than my Tav's/Durge's and his. I'm not sure what you saw on TikTok (someone must have made some not great choices), but it's one of the best romance lines I've ever experienced in a game. if you choose the good ending and support Astarion staying exactly who he is (no ascension) Astarion comes out stronger as a person, wiser Yes, Astarion's romance works really well if you play a good/resisting Durge. For example, I notice that a lot of people favour Astarion with Dark Urge because they have a lot of shared content and can easily fit into either an evil power couple dynamic or the dynamic of flawed individuals who eventually grow and develop together. I think if you play this game lawfully good it's extremely hard to. I've been watching videos of Baldur's Gate 3 and I pretty much love Astarion at this point. But to the good aligned Tavs: What do you tell yourselves to convince your good aligned character is a good match for this broody, gore loving, sarcastic evil vampire who kind of doesn't ask to be fixed and would definitely get you killed for being a goody two-shoes if he didn't need you in the start. They aren't all THAT evil by dnd standards either. It doesn't matter how much he approves of you, or if you broke down his barriers over time - letting him ascend automatically turns him into a To romance Astarion, you do either have to be ignorant to his manipulation or outright accept it to get ant pay off later. Tell He also appreciates acts of defiance, such as crushing the illithid tadpole or telling Raphael to piss off, so he will respect a strong-willed good character. Replaying now as a good Dark Urge and it's even better. There's a lot of bonus dialogue for this particular pairing, but honestly, I don't really see the chemistry. Home of the magic search button and endless book recommendations as well as discussions about tropes and characters, Author AMAs, book clubs, and more. Plus you can use this playthrough to figure out what makes Astarion tick. Tav is supposed to be the exception to that outlook. I got astarion to medium (I’ve already killed the goblin leaders but am not finishing the quest with zevlor because astarion rejects me as his approval is medium XD) I’ve had him feed off me, done deceptive choices etc. Some Dec 9, 2024 · Discover how to gain Astarion's approval in Baldur's Gate 3 Act 1 as a good character with these insightful tips! Baldur’s Gate 3 Reddit users discuss the nuances of gaining Astarion’s approval as a good character in Act 1. I was recommended to play as a paladin since it naturally aligns with my real life. i like their similarities regarding a sense of hunger they share from two different sources. In Astarion’s case, as much fun as the idea of a “redemption arc” is for him, I don’t really see it happening. Yeah Gale is the character I’m most torn between with Lae’zel. He also won’t approve OR disapprove if you do good things as long as you ask for compensation. I restarted the game, this time with Astarion as the main character (an anti-hero chaotic good type) and Karlach as my love interest. His approval only needs to be at medium level to start the romance in act 1. " Without any spoilers, can anybody please telll me if romancing (or even just relationships in general) characters when playing as an origin character is unique compared to playing as TAV?? And if so, does anyone have any favorite combos? (For example, I know people often claim Durge/Astarion romance is really great. For me, an evil character doesn’t seem to land on the romancee as naturally as the chaotic/neutral (or chaotic neutral lol) character. I did not romance Astarion on my first play through, but even playing a mostly good person had his approval very high pretty quickly. So powerful and moving, and the first time a story of trauma and healing felt like it was written in a way that felt real and relatable to me as a survivor myself. He’s really not that hard to romance. He disapproves of a fair bit, but if you're cautious and don't just go flying into everything, it isn't as hard to build up approvals to counteract them. Did you end up deciding who to go for? I've romanced them both up until a point in act 2 where Astarion makes me choose and I am so torn Without spoilers, all I know is that Good Durge and Shadowheart have a special connection. Have you discovered his 'secret' yet? You can get a good 20 points of approval, I believe, depending on how you handle that: let him bite you. And his romance is amazing - I always do it as a good character and the push and pull emotional rollercoaster on that path is so fun and rewarding. i feel like these two would grow to understand each other and see the other beyond Yes, although I did give him the book. All right. He never waivers on this. I think it depends on the character you want to play and the story you want to tell. My question is, is that enough for his romance scenes to trigger when the time comes? I really dislike ascended Astarion, and he clearly has a bigger impact on his personality, given Durge is a player character, but I still found it a good parallel, just the fact that these are the two in the party who can be REALLY evil, who can truly go towards the worst possible path. Takes me out of the immersion. Lots of parallels between these two & how they deal with the temptation of power, and how they deal with not feeling good enough For a twist though, I loooove the Astarion & Karlach romance to friendship path if you're playing as Karlach. I’ve read that you must resist the urge and Bhaal if you want dark urge to stay with Astarion in the end. I hear it's quite a treat! I romanced Shadowheart as Tav (custom character) and it was 10/10 the whole way through! I've heard Astarion is good as well, but I don't have experience with it. Astarion seems to really enjoy my characters silver (sometimes sarcastic) tongue, and talking herself out of trouble is her favorite strategy. The Astarion scene triggers, at present, are either talking with Araj Oblodra at Moonrise Towers and not forcing him to let her bite him, or killing Yurgir for Raphael in return for Raphael reading Astarion's scars. I normally play a generally good character that has "grey moments", & his rapport always ends up higher than I anticipate. If you want to make sure he's not too annoyed with him, play as a tsundere; say you won't help but then help anyway. I'm playing it for the second time, romancing Gale. Yeah for some reason every character but Astarion triggers dialogue first here. Astarion’s character at least seems more ostentatious so the unwanted flirty thing even if annoying fits his character. Yes, during this run I chose options that companion Astarion would disapprove. I honestly think UA + releasing the Spawn so the Spawn Haven happens is richest vein for world-building. Are there any tips to romancing Astarion? I looked it up and it just said "be nice to monsters, but also be a tad cruel an materialistic. Shart is the type of character that I would typically go for a first romance (which I did), but I actually liked Karlach's romance better, even though I prefer Shart's story. I love his character design, voice and I love men who are cold af but warm up to you after a while (Snape is my fav baby), but Astarion seems to like us just to f*** and I've been through too much real life bullsh*t to live this out in a game again. I couldnt help but love astarion but it conflicts with my good boy persona is it possible to romance him while still playing as a good character Astarion’s is definitely the most compelling, feels very authentic and well-written. e. I have a question about the ending for dark urge and Astarion. In act 1 to counter all of the -1s, I had to do some but not all of: 1. Astarion experiences, quite possibly, the most growth out of all the companions. I make some morally questionable decisions here and there, but mostly stay a good girl (help tieflings, etc. What book/ Book series can I find that has characters like that that isn't Gentlemen Bastards (which I've read)? Given high enough approval all the companions will initiate a romance in Act 1 even if you've never flirted with them. Regardless of the player's good/evil actions, the romance is only dependent on 1) Having a high approval and 2) The player making choices that align with the character wants in their personal quest. I really love the dynamic of a good, save everyone Tav and Astarion. I expected a cliche vampire toxic romance, and boy did this romance make me reevaluate my initial thoughts and opinions about the character 🥲 Great story telling, great way to make the player feel tons of emotions, I can guarantee you'll cry at a point if you keep going for the good ending. Gale's romance is also really, REALLY good, but you get to know him pretty well without romancing him. Lae'zel and Astarion have most amount of romance scenes out of all the other companions iirc, and those two are the ones that need character development the most so it just makes sense that their romance path are "objectively best" from a writing perspective since they will be more narratively and emotionally satisfying. A lot of people who romance Astarion do good playthroughs. Is there anyway I can make this work or should I just romance someone else? I saw another post asking a similar question but I wanted to see if I can get a few more answers so I apologize if this post is redundant. Astarion is definately a bad guy. You learn a lot more about Astarion in a romance run than you do otherwise, and he gets some additional sort of closure at the end of his story. Doesnt mean he's not allowed to have redeemable features or soft stops. Astarion engages in gross flattery and self-aggrandazing behavior. It starts off a bit like, he thinks the fact that you're fucked up is kinda hot, which honestly worried me a bit as I thought that's where it was going. Spawn were a hugely ignored facet of the DnD mythos, Astarion is one of the only ones with any amount of depth, and it'd be such a waste to throw all that away for what amounts to another Vampire Lord. Biased, but I would say Gale, because he (as I read) doesn't work things out in healthy way for himself on his own. xyiuwp hplg afmr nnegkb dwwjxvd grcwc flkxcf uia neyvz hlqpbery