Ice axe vs ice pick reddit See full list on outdoorgearlab. 4-To purchase a technical axe. 100% agree with this. It's not the same as a Gully, Sum'tec, or Akila. That’s why many more advanced climbers prefer shorter axes - they just don’t need the ax until things are quite steep, they’re fine with ski poles or nothing until then, and on that steep terrain a shorter ax will be better for swinging or dagger position or other things than As a beginner, without any friends practicing this sport to give me advice, the first ice axe I bought was a Petzl Summit Evo of 59cm. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. If you have to carry 2 axes the gully may be a better choice for the ice part, and a light general ice axe (you don't need a long shaft). Different styles of picks have different applications. Ice ax length depends as much on steepness of terrain as on height, the steeper the terrain the shorter the ax. 5kn bending strength in the test configuration, although realworld in a snow anchor is higher since the load is more evenly spread)— some tools definitely exceed the standard with forged/milled one piece shaft construction, but I absolutely wouldn’t use the shaft as a I bought a couple of Petzl sum'tec ice axes and build a new head made for snow, for self arresting. Or check it out in the app stores Giant Axe+Vadon Card vs VVS Ice Axe (Magma Farming) Boots are complicated specific. Posted by u/mortalwombat- - 23 votes and 37 comments Great all around ice axe, handles steeper terrain, and is quite comfortable paired with an ice tool when it gets too steep for an axe alone. This is a B-rated/Type 1 axe that would make a great first ice axe for someone venturing into their first winter adventures. battle highpriest takes care of recovery and stands in front of things to fleetank. Those have upturned picks for more performance on vertical ice, but will have slightly worse performance during self-arrest scenarios. Get a non-technical ice axe. Except, the dual kodachis have a better strike zone and reach than the ice pick. Also, ice axes are not walking sticks and will not replace poles. Reverse curve picks are designed for sustained climbing on steep ice. Ice tools are specifically designed to climb ice. So, I would recommend the Falk or similar for climbs that are ~50 degrees or less and are likely to only require a single axe. . much easier to just change picks than trying to keep the ice-picks sharp while also using them on rock (they will also last way longer if you are not filling them constantly). Ice tools have reverse curve picks, sometimes referred to as negative curves. Would be willing to climb just about anything shy of vertical ice with it, and even short pitches of ice haven't been a problem. While sliding, the additional leverage from a longer shaft can help control pressing the pick into harder surfaces. It is super important that you buy an ice axe that is the proper length. I own a whippet and an ice axe. They'll serve you better and you'll enjoy the sport more. Ice axe should always be on your up hill side, and if you need more stability on the down hill side extend you trekking poles. Just Mountaineering, get any walking axe. However I was thinking to take it also for easy alpin climbing instead of tourist ice axe. "The TiCa Ice Tool is not a replacement for a UIAA-certified ice axe on technical terrain and should not be used where life or safety is at risk. Unfortunately, he had his ice axe and microspikes waiting for him in the post office 10 miles north of Apache Peak in Idyllwild. ) My candidates: Petzl Gully If you’re set on a “walking” ice axe, 60cm is the absolute limit for vertical progression— any longer is just too cumbersome. They would be perfect for your intended use. Michael Covington is on the cover climbing Mt Kilimanjaro I believe. They are not necessarily interchangeable. – Typically made of steel. The reverse curve makes the pick easier to remove from hard ice. I’d recommend looking at used, since many people buy long, straight axes and then realize they want something more aggressive. It's still ridiculous that the description still says "other exoitic items" may be purchased from the supplier to count toward this type of kill and everyone here and the game also says only ice pick counts. A number of years ago I switched from a longer axe (older BD Raven) to a short axe (Petzl Summit Evo) and a BD Whippet (trekking pole with an ice axe head). Petzl makes real axes that are quite light AND you can trust. Many people learn how to use an ice axe on the trail. Your ice axe should come up to your knee with your boots or shoes on. 5mm pick tip sinks like a hot knife into butter on steep, technical ice. In addition pick up a pair of the pur'ice picks for the iceclimbing and then use the standard ice picks for alpinism and mixed climbing. Word of caution: Putting on an apron doesn't automatically make you a chef. 1-To continue using the club axes (eventually will get expensive since I have to pay a small fee if the activity is on my own) 2-To purchase a classic axe. A technical ice tool will have a much more extreme shaft and pick curve which both make self arrest difficult. I would go with the lightest and shortest ice axe you can find, as you are not going to need it much hiking the whites in winter. I had even practiced with it on icy, steep slopes and had no issues. I have seen there is a wide variety of ice axes, mainly I assume I am interested in a more general purpose one such as the Petzl Summit or the BD Raven Grip. You need an ice axe. Its super quick! There are different tools for different jobs. The UIAA technical ice axe standard only requires the shaft to be as strong as a snow picket (ie not that strong— 2. Some days, all we need our axe to do is disappear in our pack, perhaps to come out in a steep or firm moment. BD Raven Pro in the longest length for easy stuff but my favourite axe was always the original Chouinard piolet 75cm with the laminated bamboo shaft because of its wonderful balance. I see a good deal on Petzl Glaciers, however, it seems that curved ice axes are preferred. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. For less steep terrain I like a shorter ice axe with a curved handle. The pick angle actually feels fairly open with the Pur’Ice pick, to the point you can scratch holds rather than swinging with very delicate/thin ice. " If I'm using an ice ax, it's because I'm in terrain where life or safety is at risk, otherwise I'd just be sticking with my poles. There are a lot of ultralight ice axes on the market. The CAMP Corsa in one of the lightest certified ice axes on the market, but it is also probably the worst certified ice axe on the market. The Pick axe, Salvaged Axe, and Jackhammer will all give you the same amount of ore if you hit the shiny spot. More important than the brand name of the axe is buy Yvonn Chouinard's excellent book Climbing Ice. So, straight shaft and classic pick with negative pick clearance as my primary glacier travel tool. Options would be Grivel G-1 and the Nepal SA. So i have one axe for everything. The bigger deciding factor is the type of pick you have. Hatchets are a near instant-kill to the head, and work similarly to knives. Mar 21, 2019 · A surprisingly versatile axe considering its impressively low weight: Nearly half the weight of many of its all-mountain counterparts, it has a steel pick and proved surprisingly versatile: A solid general purpose mountaineering axe at a very good price: A solid general mountaineering axe for a great price: Rating Categories: Petzl Glacier Nov 2, 2018 · If you carry your ice-axe in the old fashioned way; slid in between your back and your pack; swapping over takes milliseconds with practice. Option would be a Petzl Summit. But if you can do that it becomes a do-everything axe, until you need a reverse a pick, keeping you safe on gentle ground and far superior to longer axes on graded terrain (esp. It's no substitute for an axe when the going gets rough. If you're a begginer and just going to do some laps on snow, there's no need for an ixe axe. This is to say that I will be using an ice axe for both climbing steep slopes and as a hiking pole. – Consists of the pick and adze. On other days, we may spend hours with one or two axes in use, perhaps climbing steps of ice or rock. It's inspirational as well as instructive. I want to buy my own ice axe. I intend on climbing Whitney this year and I need to pick up an ice axe so I can practice with it before the hike, my eye caught the Venom Ice Axe from Black Diamond, I prefer Black Diamond since I get a discount there, but does anyone have any recommendations? or will the Venom be a good axe for what Petzl Glacier vs. As with most tools we test, we opted for the ice pick in all but the scrappiest of drytooling scenarios, since the 2. IOI should better clarify this. But i'm on the hunt for somebody more hybrid, meaning something that can be used for glacier travel and technical mountaineering in the Alps. – Consists of the pick and Alpine (ice, allround): Get a Sumtec and a Quark hammer, maybe another quark later. Since you are on budget, my suggestion is to get the cheapest walking ice axes possible, simond, omega pacific or anything on sale. The Petzl Sum'Tec is a true hybrid of a traditional ice axe and an ice tool. Curved Ice Axe Hello everyone, this is going to be my first season ice climbing and I am deciding on which ice axes to get. They collect the same resources per node, but the ice pick is faster, you can even shave 1 more swing off it by hitting the node but not the critical on the first swing then hit the critical for the rest. We carefully considered every model in this review after considering every possible option available in North America. Anyone who thinks ice axes need to be bought before boots, helmet, crampons shouldn’t be trusted. It is suppose to be used in climbing on waterfalls and mixed climbing. A gallon-sized stuff-sack filled with snow and buried might make a more effective deadman than either tool Agree with all the recommendations about browsing resale or at least shopping a sale, an ice axe is an ice axe but the BD Raven Pro or Petzl Summit are the go-to's for me. The grip makes plunging hard if not impossible so you lose security in non technical terrain (ie petzl nomic). Jan 29, 2015 · Self-arrest takes some practice, but the same must be said of the classic ice-axe. Full Specifications Lengths: 58cm, 66cm, 74cm / B-rated / 4 colours: black, pink, blue, green / steel head and aluminium shaft / adjustable leash with a rubber tip / plastic blade cover. For reference I'm 6' and use a 55cm axe. My advice would be to borrow, rent, or purchase a set of ice tools. I want to use them both on ice and mixed climbing in lower grades and also as single ice axe for skitouring, i prefer something lighter even at the cost of durability, since i wont be using them that many times in a sesons, alason something less curved and technical than nomics. Still bring your poles. Both came with leash. The rock and stone axe of course giving you less ore and also being slower. The easiest way to distinguish an ice axe from an ice tool is the shape of the pick. From more technical models that blur the lines of what could be used for even water ice climbing to Ultralite models for alpine rock, ski-mountaineering, or spring backpacking trips on the PCT. An ice axe is much more versatile. 3-To purchase a not so classic axe. geared towards damage and vvs elemental haeddongums for variety. Both the pick and the axe side have good bite and work well for self arresting. Make sure you don't buy one that is too tall. 4 ounces for the 50cm length, this is the lightest CEN-B rated ice axe in the world. Found this comment made by u/Cyrcle. Also just for the easier to get replacement picks. Regarding ice axes don't get hung up on the old "it needs to reach your ankles" too much - I personally rather take a slightly more technical (bent & shorter) ice axe, because it will be more versatile in the long run. Ice-axes have an almost guaranteed chance to make your opponent bleed on hit, but don't do much damage at all anymore. You can also tape the shaft off the axe; coat it with grippy rubber (like what's used on pliers handles); or select grippy gloves (the grip of the fingers and palms of various gloves is a constant topic of conversation among ice climbers). Most people aren’t doing sustained ice climbing on lines that they want to ski down. If you're just doing standard mountaineering without any ice climbing, get the downward pick. The downward pick helps with self-arrest primarily. A pick built for glacier travel won't swing into ice as easily as a pick built for ice climbing. I'm 173 cm height (5'8 ) I soon realised this ice axe was too long for the routes I'm taking, and now I'm selling it and looking for an alternative (or I might keep it for glaciers. Apr 11, 2024 · The performance we seek from an ice axe varies widely depending on the day’s objective. Similarly, carrying an ice axe doesn't make you an alpine mountaineer. Head – The shorter section of the ice axe. May 13, 2013 · The axe will be used in "Piolet Traction" ("pulling on the ice axe"). I climb in the Cascades with a mountaineering organization, and they usually lend me gear, but now I think I'm ready to purchase my own ice axe. Petzl Gullys or SumTecs are really neat in that regard. Option would be Sum'tec In theroy if you acually thinking about jamming the axe into cracks then you need a T rated axe, but I highly double you would do so based on your experience. Pretty much the same axe but some people are specific on brands, I regularly use my raven pro but jealous of my SOs summit cause it's a cool black lol There may be snow conditions where the longer ice axe pick can penetrate deeper, providing more friction during the arrest. I would just get the Quarks. However, I have seen that some of them have a slight curvature and some don't. So, whether that's an axe or a hammer will be personal preference, but, it won't be any tool that I'd currently have for ice climbing. I think the interesting thing about this one is the claw-hammer-like adze. Longer axes will facilitate descending and downclimbing. The major difference is ice axes compared to ice tools. The difference is gather rate, the faster being better of course allowing you to farm big areas in short amount of time. com Mar 25, 2015 · I want a tool that self arrests well. There is a common misperception that an ice axe should work as a cane while walking on flat ground. I bought those ice axes in a good price (120 USD) however I'm thinking if it's may be bad for learning. Low weight is why you buy this ice axe. BD Raven, Grivel Airtech, Petzl Summit seem incredibly popular where i am from, but their chunky picks don't really stick in ice. I'm currently looking at getting a new ice axe, right now I have the Petzl Summit. However, whenever I look online for recommendations, they always say that certain axes are good for general mountaineering, but some are much better (but also more expensive). on the offhand is extra hit, zipperbears, or icepick depending on target. Although i recommend looking for a pick that does well in real ice. Non sketchy but would like a bit of a nicer hold while climbing - whippet Sketchy to point of needing one tool - ice axe Pretty sketchy with one tool - ice axe and whippet Two tools required - steep to near vertical ice Remember ice axe = boot crampons and a helmet. Weight. The whippet takes the place of the long axe, but is lighter and more useful and comfortable in general. – May have some holes in the center for leashes and carabiners. Technical ice tools are pretty great for climbing steep technical ice but suck for just about anything else. Length I often see people with ice axes that are too big for them. If you have a rubber handle) Can pair it with a single climbing axe (like a Quark) on the pitches too. A whippet is just an extra piece of insurance when skiing down. Took forever (8+ hours) because if you whiff the first strike, the second strike seems to have a smaller swing like the dual kodachis. I personally really like the swing as well, plus the increased durability of the handle without cutouts. It'll make proper self arresting more difficult. Just be sure to get the right length, the length of an ice axe is crucial. I think other companies made axes with a reverse curved pick and a straight shaft before the 90s, but I can’t find any evidence of a CAMP tool like this in the 80s. Too many people buy 50cm axes and don't understand how big of a mistake they've made. He is stat dumped with 99-93-40 on str int dex. A sharp ice axe serves no purpose (an ice tool and an ice axe a different to its of kit for different purposes). – This can be used as a handle when the ice axe is used as a walking stick. It's the brainchild of the late Uli Steck (with influence from Kilian Journet and Colin Haley, and others) who wanted a lighter less technical ice tool that could perform the basic functionalities of an ice axe, without giving up a pick that offers a high level of technical performance. This is not so much for pure ice climbing, but I would love to be able too strike the ice if I end up meeting it on a climb. Somehow the mantra "the absolute longest an ice axe should be is that the spike hits your ankle" was twisted into "the spike should hit your ankle. It has a very fast moveset especially when two-handed, it has a pretty high physical damage given how fast it is, its has cold build-up and a weapon art that increases cold build-up from range, and it a light weapon allowing you to wear heavier armor more easily. As of March 16 (averaged between different type of nodes) Stone Pick Axe: (100 Durability) : 26 seconds per node / 1771 Stone per minute, 767 Metal per minute, 238 Sulfur per minute Pick Axe: (400 Durability) : 32 seconds per node / 1875 Stone per minute, 813 Metal per minute, 250 Sulfur per minute Salvaged Ice Pick: (150 Durability) : 24 seconds per node We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. There's also a dredgable piece of Refined Metal that is very precious if you're doing a "No research, no shopping" run as it unlocks the T3 hull without the risk you take trying to get the dredgable one in Devil's Spine (very dodgy cos whilst you have Banish and Manifest to use, your boat hull is an absolute potato). In summary, if you're someone who hikes and climbs in moderate terrain and are looking for a lightweight, simple, yet reliable ice axe, then the Petzl Glacier, according to many online reviews, would be a strong contender. I plan to learn ice and mix climbing this winter. At 7. Whatever long axe you can afford will serve you well. It will work better Hey guys, I was wondering if anyone has any recommendations for ice axes for mountaineering. It's much harder with a straight tool, but it's very possible. The goal of the Sum'tec is to work as a classic ice axe and a technical tool (to avoid carrying 2 axes I guess) as said in the others comments. Selection Process. Nov 15, 2024 · The Hydra also comes with three pick options: ice, mixed, and dry. The weight shouldn't matter too much. A second tool could be a more technical tool and typically that'd be a Ice Axe: Ice Tool: Head – The shorter section of the ice axe. A leash helps, as jfb also mentioned. I wonder why there is a notch like that? Maybe for prying out drive in ice pitons? Cool axe! We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. If someone is having problems with rental ice axes it’s because they lack skill and training. As for dead-man/T-slot style anchors, the only ice-axes I own are not enough longer than the Rebels to make an appreciable difference. A curved shaft ice axe can make it easier to self arrest (ie petzl summit). Out of the one-handed weapons, most knives just make people bleed, but do high damage to the head. May 15, 2024 · The pick and spike corrosion resistant tip will have you using this ice axe for seasons to come. Mar 21, 2019 · However, it, along with the nearly identically designed CAMP Corsa Nanotech, was the least comfortable axe to carry in self-arrest position (pick backward), as it doesn't feel natural whatsoever. upbmnbh ixwycoqa vwtwr lbovv yyfoe biuo oswqpv tsncom baluou jqdjnu